Abstrict

Language plays an indispensable role in human communication. It has many forms, and each form has specific goals. This research explores the intricate interplay of semiotic elements within the iconic animated television series, Simpsons, across multiple seasons. Language in its multiple manifestations can also play a significant role in determining the relation between fiction and reality. The researchers have opted for a qualitative approach to analyzing the data in this regard. The most relevant Seasons were targeted and specific scenes of the selected episodes from these Seasons analyzed critically. The study focused on ten predictions that relate to real-life events. In the semiotic analysis, the researchers targeted two levels of meaning: denotative and connotative. The first referred to literal meanings whereas the second more profound and contextualized ones. The findings illustrate that semiotics, in its various dimensions play a significant role in the predictions of subsequent realities in the Simpsons.

Keywords

Fiction, Reality, Semiotics, Predictions, Simpsons

Introduction

Language plays an important role in order to communicate or interact with social beings, but it does not depend only on words. It has various forms, such as signs, symbols, images, and gestures, which portray the meanings. Therefore, communication does not merely depend only on words but rather on signs and symbols as well. According to Rose (2001: 69), "Semiotics provides a full box of analytical tools for breaking down an image and tracking how it functions with larger systems of meaning". Semiotics' primary objective is to clarify the workings of signals so that their meaning are comprehensible. It makes it easier to recognize signs, especially ones with hidden meanings. Instead of defining meaning, the phrase 'signifying practices' refers to the process of producing meaning (Potts, 1996). Semiotics, also known as semiology, is the study of signs and symbols and how they are comprehended in different situations (Barthes, 1964). The purpose of semiotics is to determine the norms and codes that influence the way signs are generated and understood within the context of a specific community. It looks at how symbols convey ideas, opinions, and ideologies, as well as how they affect our perception of the outside world. 

Semiotics pioneer Ferdinand de Saussure argued that a sign is comprised of two distinct components: the signifier and the signified (Barthes, 1964). The signifier is the physical representation of the sign, such as an expression, picture, or gesture. In contrast, the signified is the notion or significance that is associated with the sign in the mind. The link between the signifier and the signified is arbitrary and culturally identified, which is why different cultures perceive the same sign differently. It examines how signs operate at varying levels of communication, including body language, visual images, gestures, colour, sound, and cultural practices. It discovers how signs are developed and subsequently produce certain meanings in different cultural contexts, shedding light on meaning-making processes along with their underlying structure.

Moreover, Semiotics highlights the basic concepts of denotation and connotation in meaning making processes (Barthes, 1964). Whereas denotation is a sign's literal, surface-level meaning, connotation is an extra layer of context-dependent and culturally created meaning. A code is a guideline that produces various interpretations of a specific culture (Barthes, 1964). These codes could be social, general, linguistic, or certain colors and symbols which may have particular meanings in a given culture, subculture or situation.

Certain phenomena have been portrayed through a visual screen (movie, seasons, drama etc.) representing the idea of future events that may take place in real world. This may try to manipulate the mind of the audience and make them believe that certain agendas or acts are disclosed in the fictional world before they turn out to be realities. The animated sitcom, the Simpsons, has captured the attention of audiences worldwide for almost three decades with its humorous portrayal of American culture created by Matt Groening. The seasons expertly blend elements of fiction and reality within its colorful and hilarious universe. It has twenty-four Seasons. The seasons are based on the average middle-class family consisting of the main characters, i.e. Mart, Lisa, Maggie, Homer, and Bart. The Simpsons is a fictional depiction of Springfield, an American town that serves as an example of society. Through political satire, familial issues, and pop culture references, the Simpsons deftly parodies the real-world events, inspiring the viewers to contemplate their own lives and surroundings critically (Gray, 2006). According to Buanani (2021), the concept of the prediction was examined adeptly here. He specified prediction as an act of speculating about future occurrences that are based on the current behavior of a phenomenon. Its four stages illustrate that prediction research is carried out methodically. Thus, it was believed that the Simpsons predicted numerous events in a range of fields, such as sociology, politics, and economics in a sarcastic manner.

Research Question

How are the semiotic aspects incorporated in the Simpsons to augment the impact of predictions?

Research ObjectResearch Objectiveive

The study is meant to highlight the semiotic facets of the Simpsons seasons in the perspective of their predictions.

Literature Review

The relationship between prediction and reality has been established since the time immemorial. However, the concept of reality may not be fixed for all. It varies person to person, community to community, society to society, culture to culture and religion to religion. The key concepts of the study have been elaborated comprehensively in the following:

Reality in General

To explore reality, writers often employ realistic narrative representations that reflect, examine, and replicate the real world. Realist writing strives to accurately depict reality by featuring people, situations, and settings that resemble everyday life (Watt, 1959). Yet, postmodern fiction challenges conventional notions of reality by innovating with form, language, and perspective (Hutcheon, 1988). Readers' assumptions about what is real and what is portrayed are often challenged by these novels, which regularly blur the boundaries between reality and fiction.

However, the aspects that are socially produced objectively and subjectively determine that reality is a complicated and multidimensional notion and fiction provide important insights into how reality is understood, represented, and defined. Scholars can gain a deeper knowledge of reality and its implications for individuals and society by critically analyzing various perspectives.

Reality in General

To explore reality, writers often employ realistic narrative representations that reflect, examine, and replicate the real world. Realist writing strives to accurately depict reality by featuring people, situations, and settings that resemble everyday life (Watt, 1959). Yet, postmodern fiction challenges conventional notions of reality by innovating with form, language, and perspective (Hutcheon, 1988). Readers' assumptions about what is real and what is portrayed are often challenged by these novels, which regularly blur the boundaries between reality and fiction.

However, the aspects that are socially produced objectively and subjectively determine that reality is a complicated and multidimensional notion and fiction provide important insights into how reality is understood, represented, and defined. Scholars can gain a deeper knowledge of reality and its implications for individuals and society by critically analyzing various perspectives.

Reality in General

To explore reality, writers often employ realistic narrative representations that reflect, examine, and replicate the real world. Realist writing strives to accurately depict reality by featuring people, situations, and settings that resemble everyday life (Watt, 1959). Yet, postmodern fiction challenges conventional notions of reality by innovating with form, language, and perspective (Hutcheon, 1988). Readers' assumptions about what is real and what is portrayed are often challenged by these novels, which regularly blur the boundaries between reality and fiction.

However, the aspects that are socially produced objectively and subjectively determine that reality is a complicated and multidimensional notion and fiction provide important insights into how reality is understood, represented, and defined. Scholars can gain a deeper knowledge of reality and its implications for individuals and society by critically analyzing various perspectives.

Reality in Simpsons

The Simpsons is extensively renowned for its ingenious satire and social commentary, typically imitating the features of American culture and current events (Gray, 2006). In addition, the show discovers the ups and downs of family life, patenting challenges to marital issues and economic struggles. All these aspects are portrayed in the Seasons with a mixture of sincerity and humor. Simpsons depicts American society as the fictional town. That is named Springfield. It acts as a microcosm of American society, representing cultural background and reflecting real-world dynamics such as economic crises, issues of prejudice etc. Moreover, the Simpsons has further blurred the lines between fiction and reality by serving as an inspiration for countless parodies, memes, and cultural references (Gray, 2006). As a result, the show has affected how viewers interact with and perceive their environment.

What is Semiotics?

A Semiotics-Related Notion

Terms like sign, signifier and signified have generated important debate in semiotics. The word "sign" is derived from the Latin word which means "signum" or "mark". It represents or refers to something meaningful (Wales, 2014). De Saussure (1916) claims that language is a deposit of signs which refers to the phenomenon of acoustic image. Whereas a signifier refers to some form of meaning. However, the signified is produced by the signifier. The relationship between the two combines to create the physical presence of 'signification". Pierre (1991) considered sign as 'something that, in some way or another, represents something to someone, represents something in one way or another'. Conferring to Eco (1976) 'The primary focus of semiotics is on signs as social forces. Pragma-semiotics primarily emphasizes that "the sign depends for its meaning on the context in which it is communicated in the first place’’ (Watson & Hill, 1993).

The significance of symbols, images, colors and pictures cannot be ignored in semiotics. A symbol is considered a sign, creating a relation between the items, and symbolizing in the social context (Abrams, 1998).According to Culler (1981) symbols are used to convey complex ideas and emotions. Whereas the image is considered a visual representation. As described by Danesi (2016) image is interpreted to identify the meaning or convey the message to the audience or can relate the situation to real social context. Barthes (1977) stated that images are potent semiotic instruments that can be used in everyday life, art, or the media. These are pictures that, by using composition, color, and symbols, can express intricate meanings in digital media portraying new semiotic meaning (Shifman, 2014). Moreover, color makes the image clearer and more visual, which makes it more exciting. A picture is known as a portrait, sketch, cartoon, or photograph. According to Williamson (1978), the picture is essential to the communication process since specific colors chosen for an advertisement may evoke certain connections or feelings. It is used for an indication, depiction, or interpretation; all three aspects may also be reflected through it collectively, making it iconic (Watson & Hill, 1993). Three essential philosophies are often useful when observing a semiotic system, such as semantics or imageries philosophies, which are critical for talented speakers: 1) Semioticians state that the world is observed through signs (Chandler, 2001). 2) Gestural meanings are produced by people, and are unique to them and their sociocultural contexts (Schriver, 1997). 3) People may have access to a variety of tools for connotation formation through semiotic systems (Lemke, 1990)

According to Barthes (2005), semiotics may be used to analyze a variety of signs and items that have significance even in the absence of a communication goal, such as furniture, dishes, and clothes. In the view of Barthes (1990), nothing can be meaningless. According to Argyle and Cook (1994) Signs is not static but varies across different cultural and situational setting. The color of a phone, for instance, might have multiple meanings. For instance, pink phones are connected to femininity or womanhood, whereas white phones are connected to luxury. Anything, including food, wine, and beverages, is perceived as a part of a certain discourse based on its connotation (Barthes, 1968). 

Methodology

This section discusses the semiotic approach to find out the relationship between fiction and reality throughout the seasons. The main agenda of this study was to identify the semiotic aspects to find out the similarities between fiction and reality.

Connotation

Connotation is seen as the second level of interpretation, which includes signifiers and signified (Barthes, 1968). A sign that is effectively inferred from the signifier of a denotative sign is referred to as connotative. Several kinds of connotative meanings are linked with the denotation. According to Fiske (2010), a sign's connotative meaning relates to its "cultural meaning". When a term is attached, it describes the interaction that takes place when the reader's emotions and cultural values are met by the sign. Signs perform within limitation of the cultural norms that govern their use and can represent objects, behavior, and notions (McNeil, 1992). Istiynato.et.al (2024) stated that connotations are used to express emotional and cultural meaning of society. Barthes (1968) argued that we must read and pay close attention to a sign to uncover its infinite variety of meanings, rejecting the notion that a sign has a single level of meaning.

Semiotic Analysis

In order to answer the research question (How are the semiotic aspects incorporated to augment the impact of predictions in the Simpsons?) the researchers took the guidance from Barthes Theory of Semiotics (BTS). It helped the process of identifying the symbolic meaning of signs, gestures, and images shown in the seasons. Barthes (1968) claims that signs have two levels of interpretation: denotation, which is observed as the fundamental level and connotation, which is regarded as the secondary level. The researchers captured the images from the seasons and critically analyzed the image denotatively (literal meaning) and connotatively (cultural meaning).

Theoretical Underpinnings

Language plays a vital role when it comes to communicate. It may not only lead to words, but it can also produce actions through gestures, signs or symbols. When it comes to analyzing the semiotic perspective, Barthes Theory of Semiotics may be considered a reliable source. Barthes introduced a theory of semiotics (1968) where he analyzed sign systems. Semiotics can be applied in order to analyze many types of signs or items and symbols that lack communication function. This study views the semiotic aspects in Simpsons’ seasons to identify the similarities between fiction and reality. When it comes to the layers of meaning concealed within cultural goods, Barthes' semiotics theory delves deep into the symbolic and ideological aspects of signs.

Data Collection

Based on how significant each episode was to the concept of fiction versus reality, data was taken from several Simpsons’ Seasons (3, 4, 5, 9, 11, 16, 20, 21, 23 and 28). The gestures, signs, and symbols were also visible in the visual data, and those images, signs, and symbols were captured for a more thorough examination.

Season 3, Episode 24 (Brothers, can you spare two dimes?)

Figure 1

Baby Translator Machine.





Semiotic Analysis

The picture is taken form the season three. The picture is analyzed on denotative and connotative meanings. At denotative level, the picture reflects that this is a baby translator machine, a device which is used to detect the babies' cries, whereas at denotative level it represents the upcoming advancement of future technologies as this idea was shown in a Season in 1992. It is shown as the symbol of the modern era where parents can rely on such type of machine to seek help. The device interprets the baby’s cry and decode them and answer into the plane English whether the baby is hungry or in a sleepy mood. After 20 years, the Swiss Health Tech company first invented a baby translator in 2019. The episode predicted the reality regarding modern future technologies.

Season 4, Episode 21 (Marge in Chains)

Figure 2

Osaka Flu.



Semiotic Analysis

This picture employs two levels of meaning. The first level is based on denotative, which indicates that the picture simply tells about the two working employees trying to put flu germs into the box. The second level is based on connotative which portrays that two working employees belong to a Japanese country as it can be seen through the facial features. Moreover, the infected person is packing the flu germs (virus) in order to spread worldwide. Symbolically it represents the idea of a future virus that may take place, a hint for the audience. The picture is taken from the episode (margin in Chains) where employees from Osaka, Japan try to spread the virus through the delivery boxes. From another perspective, it also demonstrates that the virus is being created on its own to infect the people, the picture shows a working employee packing the germs into a box. By looking into the reality, it appears the same virus (COVID-19), that came from China and spread throughout the world. Lastly, most of the opinions regarding the covid-19 also suggest that is was a preplanned agenda or a fabricated virus. All the predictions in the episode appear to be true in reality.

Season 5, Episode 15 (Deep Space Homer)

Figure 3

Space Travelers



Semiotic Analysis

The picture also shows two semiotic perspectives. The denotative conveys the idea of a group of people having dressed themselves in space suits in a space-themed setting. Whereas, the connotative look into the deeper symbolic meanings. Characters in the space suits portray a theme like new discovery, adventure, exploration, and teamwork. This also symbolizes the new advancement as the middle character Humor in the Simpsons acts a role as an average American and he is getting a chance to travel the space. This act indicates a human desire to push boundaries and explore beyond limits. The episode aired in 1994 at that time going to the space was not a common concept. It was an unrealistic approach. Whereas in the current scenarios it has become a common concept to travel to space. NASA offers certain opportunities for tourists and private citizen to experience the International Space Station. Hence the prediction is found to be accurate in reality.

Season 9, Episode 1 (The City of New York Vs. Homer Simpsons)

Figure 4

New York City



Semiotic Analysis

The picture is taken from the Episode (the city of New York vs. Homer Simpsons). From the semiotic perspective, the image has two levels of meaning. At denotative level, it shows a New York magazine trip and money associated with the trip. Whereas at connotative level it is interpreted differently. The number nine on the magazine represents the month of September, while the two buildings on the magazine portray the number eleven and the World Trade Center. The word ‘New York’ clearly mentioned on the top of the magazine shows the targeted place where the incident will take place in the future. Lastly, the sign of the dollar and a character holding cash indicate that it was a preplanned agenda (inside job), not an incident. The episode was released in 1997 and reality appeared in 2001. Hence it is clearly shown that the prediction of 9/11 made by the Simpsons appears in reality.

Season 11, Episode 17 (Bart to future)

Figure 5

American Crises



Semiotic Analysis

The picture portrays two levels of interpretations. The denotative level conveys the idea of a group of people getting together, from their dresses it seems a meeting is going on between the boss and employees. While at connotative level, the background of the picture is portrayed as a parliament house. The flag of America is shown in the background and the female character sitting in the middle represents the president of America. The rest of the characters represent the members of the parliament. However, this picture also conveys the idea that the characters might be discussing some serious issues, it also presents a symbol of responsibilities towards their citizens and fulfilling their rights, promises, and needs. It indicates the teamwork effort for the better future of America.

Season 16, Episode 15 (Future Drama-Hover Car)

Figure 6

Hover Car





Semiotic Analysis

The denotative meanings convey simply the idea of a car or a luxury car that can fly. Whereas the connotation meaning indicates the symbols of new inventions and new future projects. It also reflects modernization and how the world will be changed in terms of technology. All these aspects relate to current advancements.

Season 16, Episode 15 (Future Drama-Clones)

Figure 7

Clones.



Semiotic Analysis

Semiotic Analysis

The picture is also taken from the episode-15 to analyze the semiotic perspective. The denotative level shows two identical persons that might be twin brothers. But at connotative level the picture is described as a symbol of biological power and how geneticists can develop an identical human species from a single gene. The characters in the picture are portrayed as Moe and the second is Moe clones the duplicate. The clone is a man-made invention that resonates with the original person. The picture shows both characters having the same skin color, eye color, hair color, and body posture. On the other side, it also shows as a symbol of destruction as well, this may affect society, considering yourself as real as you may not be. A person can create a baby according to his needs like changing skin color, eyes color, gender but it is unethical in some countries to do so, however, cloning of animals and plants is considered more common. All these prediction can be seen in current era.

Season 16, Episode 15 (Future Drama-Plastic Surgery Center)

Figure 8

Plastic Surgery Center.



Semiotic Analysis

The picture is also taken from episode-15 of the future drama. From the semiotic aspect, the denotative level of meaning illustrates the surgical center for the specific body parts. Whereas at connotative level it reflects a symbol of beauty, where women can enhance their beauty according to their needs. Secondly, the words on the building itself portray a symbol of new advancements where you can enhance beauty by not only doing a makeover but also through a surgical process that may last forever. Such as fillers, face-lifts, botox injections, and facial fillers for wrinkles are part of plastic surgeries, and women can maintain their beauty through these procedures. All these aspects can be seen in the current era. Plastic surgeries are considered to be common nowadays. By analyzing from the semiotic view, it has clearly shown that predictions made in this episode regarding future advancement were proven in today's world. 

Season 20, Episode 4 (Tree House of Horror XIX)

Figure 9

Faulty Error Machine



Semiotic Analysis

Looking from the Semiotic viewpoint, the denotative meaning simply conveys the impression of a character or an average citizen who is giving his vote in a polling station. Whereas the connotative meaning serves as the symbol of citizens' rights, indicating the responsibility of vote. It also shows that everyone has one’s own choice to choose the president for the better future of the country. The picture shows that Homer Simpsons tries to give a vote to Obama but the polling machine causes an error and votes for Mitt Romney. This incident creates Homer's panic. Additionally, this prediction proves itself real in Pennsylvania in the year 2012.

Season 21, Episode 19 (The Greatest Story of ever d’ohed)

Figure 10

The Greatest Story of ever d’ohed



Semiotic Analysis

The picture denotatively portrays that America is supporting or helping Israel consistently. Meanwhile, connotative meaning portrays how America is using Israel just to take control of the world, the sentence 'your American tax dollars at work' illustrates that America is providing the weapons to Israel for the destruction, as Jews want to kill Palestinians to occupy the place completely. Secondly, it also portrays that America is playing a hidden role, usually not coming to the front line and not revealing itself rather using other hands. All these aspects can be seen in the current era, how Palestinians are being targeted by Israel with American support.

Season 21, Episode 19 (The Greatest Story of ever d’ohed-Worship Tomb)

Figure 11

Worship Tomb.



Semiotic Analysis

The picture is also taken from season 21. From a semiotic point of view, the denotatively this picture represents a tomb or a worship place, whereas looking connotatively it represents the symbol of strength, unity, power, and faith. Moreover, looking deeper into it shows the belief or faith of the Palestinian people in its possession. The tomb shown in the Season represents the dome of the rock portraying the safest place for the Palestinian people. On the other hand, it represents a threat or destruction for the Israelites.

Season 23, Episode 17 (Them, Robot)

Figure 12

Robots.



Semiotic Analysis

Analyzing through the semiotic lens, the picture describes two levels of meaning. The first is the denotative level describing the image as a working robot machine that helps humans and reduces the workload, whereas the second level of meaning is connotation portraying the image as a symbol of AI advancements, unemployment for humans, and destruction for humans as it will replace them. Also portrayed as a symbol of new advancements for the future. Hence, it has been proven that many countries worldwide are seeking help from robots, countries such as Japan, China, and many more have started relying on Artificial Intelligence. 

Season 28, Episode 2 (Friends and Family)

Figure 13

Virtual Glass.



Semiotic Analysis

From the semiotic lens, the denotation level conveys the idea of virtual glass, which we can see and feel-through. The connotative meaning represents the symbol of escaping reality and trying to fit into the world of fantasy or living in a fake world. Moreover, this virtual glass fulfills the needs or desires of the human in the current era. It also represents the symbol of new advancement in future technologies. Hence, all these aspects can be seen in reality, the virtual glasses were predicted in 2016 and reality appeared in 2024, named as Apple Vision Pro. 

Findings

The two different levels of signs and their relevant frequencies are appended below:

Table 10

Semiotic level

Level of Signs	Frequency
Denotation	13
Connotation	13

The above table discusses the semiotic meaning based on two levels: Denotative and Connotative. The BTS was a great help to identify the resemblance between fiction and reality. The total number of frequency found on both level of meanings is astonishingly similar. Different pictures taken from the selected seasons portray different meanings that resonate with reality. Moreover, the denotative level relies on the context's literal and surface meanings. While the connotative meanings rely on the deeper meaning of the context i.e. analysis of the picture from its various perspectives. It is clearly proven that the Simpsons’ seasons provide the meaningful predictions through the context/settings constituting deeper meanings.

Conclusion

The ability to comprehend the hidden message of utterance is highly important. The study aimed to investigate the semiotic aspects in the Simpsons’ seasons to discover the real-life events shown in the seasons. For this purpose, Barthes' theory was used as required. Basically, it represents two levels of meanings: denotative and connotative. Denotative refers to surface meaning, whereas connotative refers to deeper meaning. In other words, the speaker intends and has a particular function in mind when employing certain symbols or signs in the process of communication. The denotative aspect of semiotics is used to represent the literal meanings of words or signs, or symbols clearly. Majority of the audience or viewers can easily understand the denotative level of meaning because those signs, symbols, or images do not demand more linguistic acquaintance and semiotic understanding. However, the connotative level is used to signify the deeper meaning, which require deeper comprehension of the viewers or audience to interpret the signs or images. The study significantly highlights that both connotative and denotative levels should be applied since the audience needs both to comprehend the message behind those signs, symbols, or images to access the intended message. It may help the audience to know the basic purpose or agenda behind the scenes.

References

• Argyle, M., Cook, M., & Cramer, D. (1994). Gaze and mutual gaze. The British Journal of Psychiatry, 165(6), 848–850. https://doi.org/10.1017/s0007125000073980

• Barthes, R. (1968). Elements of semiology. Hill and Wang.

• Barthes, R. (1977). Image-music-text (S. Heath, Trans.). Hill and Wang.

• Barthes, R. (1990). Mythologies. Hürriyet Yayınları.

• Barthes, R. (2005). Semiological adventure. YKY.
• Bayav, D. (2006). Interpersonal communication. Sage.
• Brown, D. (2010). Techniques of television production. Palgrave Macmillan.
• Chandler, D. (2001). Signs: Semiotics for beginners. Routledge.

• Chatman, S. (1978). Story and discourse: Narrative structure in fiction and film. Cornell University Press.

• Danesi, M. (2016). The semiotics of emoji: The rise of visual language in the age of the internet. Bloomsbury.
• e Saussure, F. (1916). Course in general linguistics (W. Baskin, Trans.). McGraw-Hill.
• Dyer, G. (2008). Advertising as communication. In Routledge eBooks. https://doi.org/10.4324/9780203158340
• ECO, U. (1976). A Theory of Semiotics. Indiana University Press. http://www.jstor.org/stable/j.ctt16xwcfd

• Fiske, J. (2010). Introduction to communication studies. Routledge.

• Gray, J. (2006). Watching with the Simpsons: Television, parody, and intertextuality. Routledge.
• Griffin, S. (2016, January 14). The Simpsons' earliest predictions yet: From smart watches to Greece's financial collapse. The Telegraph.
• Hutcheon, L. (1988). A poetics of postmodernism: History, theory, fiction. Routledge.
• Kress, G., & van Leeuwen, T. (2006). Reading images: The grammar of visual design (2nd ed.). Routledge.
• Lemke, J. L. (1990). Talking science: Language, learning, and values. Ablex Publishing Corporation.
• Panofsky, E. (1970). Meaning in the visual arts. Penguin.
• Potts, A. (1996). Sign. In R. Nelson & R. Shiff (Eds.), Critical terms for art history (pp. 370-379). University of Chicago Press.
• Rose, G. (2001). Visual methodologies: An introduction to the interpretation of visual materials. Sage.
• Schriver, K. (1997). Dynamics in document design. John Wiley & Sons.
• Shifman, L. (2014). Memes in digital culture. MIT Press
• Sobur, A. (2009). Semiotika komunikasi. PT Remaja Rosdakarya.
• Wales, K. (2014). A Dictionary of Stylistics. In Routledge eBooks. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781315833507
• Watson, J., & Hill, A. (1993). A dictionary of communication and media studies (3rd ed.). Edward Arnold.
• Watt, I. (1959). The rise of the novel: Studies in Defoe, Richardson, and Fielding. Univ of California Press.
• Williamson, J. (1978). Decoding advertisements: Ideology and meaning in advertising. Marion Boyars.
• Zoonen, L. (1994). Feminist media studies. Sage.